Comments on: November Cash Experiment: Successful, Perhaps

By: Sarah

Sarah — Wed, 03 Dec 2008 11:03:38 +0000

I’m trying the cash rewards thing too with Chase. Bad record keeping on my part kept things touch and go for a while, but I’m on track again. My Chase rewards card is linked to my checking account, and I transfer money weekly to keep my debt down instead of waiting for the statement. I find that I’m in better control of myself by keeping the cash and credit as close to each other as possible.

By: Andrew Chilton

Andrew Chilton — Tue, 02 Dec 2008 09:27:31 +0000

I think I’m always going to be a plastic person since I just don’t like carrying cash. In fact, I find it really easy to leave cash in my wallet (currently I have $1.60 in there and has been the same for about a week). I guess I should try this at some stage just to see the other side of the fence.

By: Writer's Coin

Writer's Coin — Tue, 02 Dec 2008 02:38:24 +0000

I’m really excited to see what happens for the rest of the year, although the holidays might skew your results too. But I’m jazzed you did this so that’s great. I talked the talk but never actually walked the walk. You are my idol.

By: kitty

kitty — Tue, 02 Dec 2008 00:16:31 +0000

It doesn’t seem conclusive to me. BTW – I spent a lot less this November than last year, and I continued using credit cards. In fact I spend very little. Why? The economy is terrible, I lost over 100K (probably 150K by now…) in my investments’ value, and while my company is doing OK (for now), my fear for my job is a whole lot stronger. I simply don’t have any desire to go shopping this month, either online or to stores.

There are a lot of changes in the economy this November to make it difficult to attribute any reduction to spending to simply changing from cards to cash.

“I can’t be positive, but for me, a debit card linked to a checking account is a cross between using a credit card and writing a check.”
How is it different from a credit card with auto-pay of full balance set up? You still to have money on your checking albeit on a specific date.

No experiments for me. I am perfectly satisfied with my spending habits and the amount of money I have left every month after expenses. I don’t need to reduce spending.

By: Flexo

Flexo — Mon, 01 Dec 2008 20:47:50 +0000

J.D.: I’m quite surprised with my lack of spending in November, but I can’t say with surety that it was fully due to my cash-only policy. It can’t hurt to extend the experiment into December; maybe the gift-giving season will put this to the test.

Tagi: There are some things I have to use a debit card. My girlfriend’s Christmas gift, for example. Any situation that calls for an online purchase I’ll use my debit card.

I can’t be positive, but for me, a debit card linked to a checking account is a cross between using a credit card and writing a check. There is no “cash” changing hands — that’s probably the biggest demotivation for spending — but there’s the knowledge that I have to have the money to cover it.

By: Tagi

Tagi — Mon, 01 Dec 2008 20:12:07 +0000

I’ve been tempted to try this credit card-free experiment as well. I, too, use cash rewards credit cards and look forward to my ‘cash back bonus’, but have heard that the mere use of credit cards causes one to overspend in the first place, thus eliminating the ‘bonus’ received from such cards. Are you using cash only, or are you using a debit card? Do you think the reduction in spending is associated with the hassle of carrying and using cash, or if it is a mental thing that works for a debit card linked directly to a checking account?

By: J.D.

J.D. — Mon, 01 Dec 2008 19:51:53 +0000

Flexo, I’m doing a similar experiment. I started it by chance, really, in early October. I’ve basically given myself an “adult allowance” of $200/month. I have been, well, shocked by how successful this has been. I’m one of those who has always discounted the “cash only” advocates, but I’m thinking about making this permanent. I’m much more conscious of my spending.

By: lulugal

lulugal — Mon, 01 Dec 2008 18:23:08 +0000

I run my finances with the rewards credit card like you do. I treat the credit card like cash…by paying it before I get hit with interest and I love gaining cash back.

I used to work at a bank and got so disgusted by some of the dirty cash I got that I try not to touch cash now if I can.

Good luck on the cash experiment.