Don’t forget Consumerism Commentary is matching charitable contributions. Consumerism Commentary readers have donated $2,100 as of this morning, resulting in a total of $4,200 designated for charity including our matching contribution. Sign up and get your donation matched before December 11!
About a decade ago, I first learned about no-load index mutual funds and, after earning money to invest after some time, began my foray into long-term investing with newfound knowledge about making the most of my money through avoiding high management fees.
The best sources for this type of information at the time were the discussion boards on The Motley Fool. I learned a lot from the participants, including some of the Motley Fool staff, about living within my means, online banking, and credit cards. For me, the Motley Fool always represented the most responsible choices for managing personal finances and investments.
Every company has to make money, and I accept that. Perhaps this was part of their offering ten years ago, and perhaps I didn’t notice it because I focused on the discussion boards rather than the official staff-written articles. Eventually I began to see the Motley Fool’s focus on investment newsletters, a fee-based service that provided investors with the latest hot stock tips. The concept of a hot stock newsletter opposed the philosophy espoused on the rest of the website.
I’m not completely surprised that the Motley Fool now offers investments. Motley Fool Funds is an asset management arm of the Motley Fool, and the team offers two actively-managed mutual funds, the Motley Fool Great America Fund (TMFGX) and the Motley Fool Independence Fund (FOOLX).
The Motley Fool Great America Fund invests in small and mid-cap companies, avoiding the S&P 500. This fund carries a gross expense ratio of 2.30%, though part of that fee is currently subsidized by the fund, resulting in a 1.35% expense ratio. The 1.35% rate isn’t bad for a managed fund, but the subsidy could end as early as February 28, 2011. Even if the subsidy never expires, it’s going to be difficult to justify these fees.
The Motley Fool Independence Fund focuses on non-US companies. After the management expense subsidy, the fees add up to 1.45%, and will return to 2.26% when the subsidy expires.
Both funds have a minimum investment requirement of $3,000 and an early redemption fee of 2% if you sell the investment within 90 days of the purchase date. If you’re interested in either of these funds, you can purchase them through a number of brokerages such as Vanguard or directly from Motley Fool Funds.
I plan on sticking with my low-cost index mutual funds for now. I have no problem with paying fees if the value I receive is beyond what is offered by the least expensive options, but when it comes to mutual funds, the data show that actively managed funds don’t beat the index over the time horizon I’m interested in, and investing with a short time horizon could pay off, but it’s too risky.
Published or updated December 8, 2010.